0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Yeah, they got f-ed by the Senate getting that "no contest" instead of the forfeit win they deserved. That hurt them a lot.
I don't really have a better solution - and I don't think the computer system is really all that bad. I suppose I was just pointing out, given Ginn's health problems and who they lost to, they were still a top D1 R1 team. But I agree, they likely weren't going to win the region - they traditionally don't play to their talent level anyway and they have fewer top recruits than usual.
Quote from: shs96 on November 02, 2011, 01:47:14 AMI don't really have a better solution - and I don't think the computer system is really all that bad. I suppose I was just pointing out, given Ginn's health problems and who they lost to, they were still a top D1 R1 team. But I agree, they likely weren't going to win the region - they traditionally don't play to their talent level anyway and they have fewer top recruits than usual.I'm usually very impressed with their play. I don't just mean by their talent either. They usually play very hard and pretty well-disciplined and they look crisp on both sides of the ball. Sure, they make some mistakes here and there, but most high school teams do.However, the only game I saw them play this year was against Ignatius, and they didn't look like the Glenville of old. Sure, they still had a good amount of talent, but not like they traditionally have had, and their offense seemed really sloppy and one-dimensional.
Quote from: shs96 on November 02, 2011, 01:47:14 AMI don't really have a better solution - and I don't think the computer system is really all that bad. I suppose I was just pointing out, given Ginn's health problems and who they lost to, they were still a top D1 R1 team. But I agree, they likely weren't going to win the region - they traditionally don't play to their talent level anyway and they have fewer top recruits than usual.I think it's the Cleveland Public School typical "high low" sporadic issues. In the majority or certain sports one or two schools were "powerhouses". In the 40s it was East Tech (central) and West Tech. In the 50s John Marshall and JFK. In the 60s it was Glenville. In the 70s it was JFK. The 80s East Tech & John Adams. The 90s Collinwood (girls track). The '00's Glenville in the majority of sports.
Quote from: MyTwoSense on November 02, 2011, 04:58:42 AMQuote from: shs96 on November 02, 2011, 01:47:14 AMI don't really have a better solution - and I don't think the computer system is really all that bad. I suppose I was just pointing out, given Ginn's health problems and who they lost to, they were still a top D1 R1 team. But I agree, they likely weren't going to win the region - they traditionally don't play to their talent level anyway and they have fewer top recruits than usual.I think it's the Cleveland Public School typical "high low" sporadic issues. In the majority or certain sports one or two schools were "powerhouses". In the 40s it was East Tech (central) and West Tech. In the 50s John Marshall and JFK. In the 60s it was Glenville. In the 70s it was JFK. The 80s East Tech & John Adams. The 90s Collinwood (girls track). The '00's Glenville in the majority of sports.Open enrollment means that the best players who think they have a chance to play college ball will congregate at the best program, where the scouts are more likely to see them. Glenville's crossed that threshold, to the point where they probably don't have to actively recruit anymore.They're seeing the same thing at Maple Heights, since it's so easy to move there these days.
I forgot about open enrollment, which I think is stupid, with exception to the specialized schools.
Quote from: E Rocc on November 02, 2011, 10:30:57 PMQuote from: MyTwoSense on November 02, 2011, 04:58:42 AMQuote from: shs96 on November 02, 2011, 01:47:14 AMI don't really have a better solution - and I don't think the computer system is really all that bad. I suppose I was just pointing out, given Ginn's health problems and who they lost to, they were still a top D1 R1 team. But I agree, they likely weren't going to win the region - they traditionally don't play to their talent level anyway and they have fewer top recruits than usual.I think it's the Cleveland Public School typical "high low" sporadic issues. In the majority or certain sports one or two schools were "powerhouses". In the 40s it was East Tech (central) and West Tech. In the 50s John Marshall and JFK. In the 60s it was Glenville. In the 70s it was JFK. The 80s East Tech & John Adams. The 90s Collinwood (girls track). The '00's Glenville in the majority of sports.Open enrollment means that the best players who think they have a chance to play college ball will congregate at the best program, where the scouts are more likely to see them. Glenville's crossed that threshold, to the point where they probably don't have to actively recruit anymore.They're seeing the same thing at Maple Heights, since it's so easy to move there these days. I forgot about open enrollment, which I think is stupid, with exception to the specialized schools.
Quote from: MyTwoSense on November 03, 2011, 03:49:25 AMQuote from: E Rocc on November 02, 2011, 10:30:57 PMQuote from: MyTwoSense on November 02, 2011, 04:58:42 AMQuote from: shs96 on November 02, 2011, 01:47:14 AMI don't really have a better solution - and I don't think the computer system is really all that bad. I suppose I was just pointing out, given Ginn's health problems and who they lost to, they were still a top D1 R1 team. But I agree, they likely weren't going to win the region - they traditionally don't play to their talent level anyway and they have fewer top recruits than usual.I think it's the Cleveland Public School typical "high low" sporadic issues. In the majority or certain sports one or two schools were "powerhouses". In the 40s it was East Tech (central) and West Tech. In the 50s John Marshall and JFK. In the 60s it was Glenville. In the 70s it was JFK. The 80s East Tech & John Adams. The 90s Collinwood (girls track). The '00's Glenville in the majority of sports.Open enrollment means that the best players who think they have a chance to play college ball will congregate at the best program, where the scouts are more likely to see them. Glenville's crossed that threshold, to the point where they probably don't have to actively recruit anymore.They're seeing the same thing at Maple Heights, since it's so easy to move there these days. I forgot about open enrollment, which I think is stupid, with exception to the specialized schools.Why should a family's choice be limited? Even if we're talking about sports, I'm 100% supportive of allowing students to attend a school that will be help them to fulfill their goals. If a student is a stellar track athlete, but would normally be assigned to Rhodes who has a terrible track program, why shouldn't they be allow to transfer to Glenville, a juggernaut track school? Doing so will allow that student to be around other successful track athletes and coaches who are the top of their field. In turn, this will help the transferring student to improve their skills and their chances of getting a scholarship.
How old are you? Seriously? I ask because our ages may influence our opinions. I'm old school. When I was in High School there was no "open enrollment" with exception to CSA, Max Hays, East/West Technical, Aviation, Jane Addams. When I was in school, if you attended one of these school but it was not you "home" school, you had to play sports at your home school. My cousin went to Max Hayes for printing tech, but had to play sports for Lincoln-West, since they lived in the L-W district. Another cousin was at Jane A. (when it was still all girls) and had to play sports at JFK.Strictly speaking on public schools, if you live in Shaker (I'm not including Shaker Sq., where parents have always had a choice of school systems), you have one choice of a public school system. Period.If the schools believed in the neighborhoods and vice-versa, both improve and there - rather - should be - parity in education and athletics.Open enrollment has made one school a powerhouse for boys sports over the last decade - Glenville. The remaining schools have suffered.
'Eye of the Tiger' is stuck in my head today. Fitting. Good to know some traditions never die and Heights still to this day runs on the field, through the tunnel made by the band, to that song.I wish I could be there on Saturday night. I would at least suggest that the tuba players put on this tune each time Ed's OL breaks huddle and waddles up to the line - Stewie Follows Fat Guy With TUBA
Last year was no fluke! Heights 56 - Toledo St. John's 24
this is so stupid.Bring back "AAA", "AA" and "A". Stop trying to make schools feel "special".This sucks for sports!
I think we should have 500 divisions so everyone can say they're champions.
Hell. I'm still in shock Shaker left the LEL. Granted Half the Old LEL teams are there now. Which makes no sense, since the Old Greater Cleveland Conference was split up (then merged into the LEL), mainly, due to travel since teams spanned three counties.
Quote from: MyTwoSense on August 26, 2012, 12:01:27 AMHell. I'm still in shock Shaker left the LEL. Granted Half the Old LEL teams are there now. Which makes no sense, since the Old Greater Cleveland Conference was split up (then merged into the LEL), mainly, due to travel since teams spanned three counties.The Northeast Ohio Conference exists, in my opinion, almost solely to accomodate the football scheduling needs a few elite public school programs (Mentor, Solon, Strongsville) and a few others that think they can someday be elite (Twinsburg, Medina, Brunswick). Personally I think this five county agglomeration won't last because it hasn't done enough to consider the needs (particularly travel) of the Olympic sports programs. Additionally there has been some backlash from some of the Summit County schools--even talks of forming a more local conference. Hopefully the NOC breaks up sooner rather than later and a new eastside version of the LEL can be formed with a big school division consisting of at least Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights, Euclid, Brush, Mayfield, Mentor, and maybe even Willoughby South, Eastlake North, and/or Solon. A new Summit County league could consist of Twinsburg, Hudson, Nordonia, Stow, Cuyahoga Falls, and maybe Solon and some others.
When the GCC broke up, the main reason was travel time and costs and parity among schools. I cant imagine wanting to cheer for my school, if I lived in Lorain and we're playing Mentor. Not to mention being a parent and traveling all those miles.I went to Shaker and would always go to any game we had against/vs. Heights, JFK or Shaw. I didn't want to drive to a Parma or Lakewood, because I thought it was far, so I cannot imagine what kids, parents, supports of these large conferences do. Its too much. Luckily the Football season schedule isn't that bad, but my brother, cousins, Aunts/Uncles and my parents are now trying to figure out how to manage attending games for other sports seasons. On top of that, since Shaker & Heights are no longer in the same league our 20 year intra family rivalry has pretty much come to end. No more smack talking unless its they meet in the playoffs.
MTS, I think we've had this discussion before, but I'm pretty sure you're referring to the WRC, which was formed from teams leaving the GCC, which wasn't all that spread out. The WRC spanned a much larger area and eventually many teams broke off into the already existing LEL to make it a two division conference.
Quote from: MyTwoSense on August 26, 2012, 05:47:32 AMWhen the GCC broke up, the main reason was travel time and costs and parity among schools. I cant imagine wanting to cheer for my school, if I lived in Lorain and we're playing Mentor. Not to mention being a parent and traveling all those miles.I went to Shaker and would always go to any game we had against/vs. Heights, JFK or Shaw. I didn't want to drive to a Parma or Lakewood, because I thought it was far, so I cannot imagine what kids, parents, supports of these large conferences do. Its too much. Luckily the Football season schedule isn't that bad, but my brother, cousins, Aunts/Uncles and my parents are now trying to figure out how to manage attending games for other sports seasons. On top of that, since Shaker & Heights are no longer in the same league our 20 year intra family rivalry has pretty much come to end. No more smack talking unless its they meet in the playoffs.All of these reasons are exactly why I was more than a little surprised and disappointed that Shaker ditched the LEL after helping to start the conference almost a century ago in favor of a Johnny-Come-Lately conference that makes almost no sense on a number of levels. Do you have any contacts at the school that can give some insight into the reasoning behind the decision?Quote from: jam40jeff on August 26, 2012, 07:42:08 AMMTS, I think we've had this discussion before, but I'm pretty sure you're referring to the WRC, which was formed from teams leaving the GCC, which wasn't all that spread out. The WRC spanned a much larger area and eventually many teams broke off into the already existing LEL to make it a two division conference.I don't know about this, from my recollection it seems like you both are sort of right on this one. Here's what I remember about the fluctuating membership of the GCC, which during its heyday I believe had nine teams (in order of departure):1. Mentor - joined LEL in early 1990s after being "asked" to leave GCC2. Euclid - joined LEL in mid or late 1990s3. Bedford - joined LEL after GCC broke up4. Maple Heights - see Bedford5. Brush - joined WRC North after GCC broke up6. Mayfield - see Brush7. Nordonia - see Brush8. Eastlake North - charter member of PAC after GCC broke up9. Willoughby South - see Eastlake North
You're forgetting about Lorain, Admiral King, Elyria, Elyria West, Lorain Southview, Painesville Riverside and I forgot the other westside GCC schools. Even after Mentor left, teams still had to travel to Lorain County.
You're forgetting about Lorain, Admiral King, Elyria, Elyria West, Lorain Southview, Painesville Riverside and I forgot the other westside GCC schools. Even after Mentor left, teams still had to travel to Lorain County. Also in play, was parity, some schools were not large enough to field V, JV and Freshmen teams. Some schools had additional sports. For example some of the schools in the area do not have Golf, Hockey, Gymnastics, indoor track(b/g), lacrosse (b/g) or boys volleyball. When I was in High School, Garfield had very few girls sports teams.I have no idea why shaker left, but some of shakers facilities are not up to snuff, the football field and track has been horrible since the 80s.
Quote from: MyTwoSense on August 26, 2012, 11:32:31 AMYou're forgetting about Lorain, Admiral King, Elyria, Elyria West, Lorain Southview, Painesville Riverside and I forgot the other westside GCC schools. Even after Mentor left, teams still had to travel to Lorain County.MTS, I think you're getting the GCC mixed up with another conference. None of those teams were ever in it, and no school west of Euclid/Brush/Maple Heights was in the conference. Clevelander17 is right about the only 9 teams to ever play in that conference, except that there were actually never more than 8 in the conference at one time (Nordonia left a couple years after Mentor left).
Quote from: MyTwoSense on August 26, 2012, 11:32:31 AMYou're forgetting about Lorain, Admiral King, Elyria, Elyria West, Lorain Southview, Painesville Riverside and I forgot the other westside GCC schools. Even after Mentor left, teams still had to travel to Lorain County. Also in play, was parity, some schools were not large enough to field V, JV and Freshmen teams. Some schools had additional sports. For example some of the schools in the area do not have Golf, Hockey, Gymnastics, indoor track(b/g), lacrosse (b/g) or boys volleyball. When I was in High School, Garfield had very few girls sports teams.I have no idea why shaker left, but some of shakers facilities are not up to snuff, the football field and track has been horrible since the 80s.A few thoughts:1) I don't recall there ever being any Lorain County schools in the GCC, at least not when the league disbanded in the mid-1990s. I'm also fairly certain that Painesville Riverside wasn't in the league at the time, either.2) Hockey and lacrosse have their own leagues which are self-governed and based on more than just enrollment, so that's never come into play with league affiliation. And in the sports of gymnastics and boys volleyball, so few schools have teams in those sports that I also believe that they don't matter in league affiliation, either.3) Shaker Heights just re-did its football field (and track, too?) and I think it looks very nice. And actually, SHHS has one of the most unique and charming high school stadium setups that I've ever come across, even if it's perhaps not as state-of-the-art as some other stadiums.One more point of clarification, now that I think about it: I actually believe Euclid joined the LEL along with Bedford and Maple Heights when the GCC disbanded. For some reason I thought Euclid joined a year or two before those two schools, but I'm not sure that's correct.